Pattern: Butterprint
Identifiers / Alternate Names: Country "Amish" Farming scene featuring farmer and wife holding a bushel of crops. Surrounding them are crops in the field, wheat sheafs tied together, roosters and corn plants. Turquoise on White and the reverse color scheme is the most common, with other possibilities being and orange-yellow on white and a pink on white color scheme. The smallest refrigerator box has no farmers on it, only the rooster and corn showing. Also known as: Amish, Farmer & Wife, Buttercup, Rooster & Corn
Item Type: 440 Series Cinderella Mixing Bowls Set
Years Manufactured: 1957 - ?
Values: Check below on Ebay for approximate prices
Sizes and ID#s: #441 (1.5 pint) #442 (1.5 quart) #443 (2.5 quart) #444 (4 quart)
Original Box#s: 440-SP

We know very little about the off-color Butterprint items, except that they do exist and are generally more rare than turquoise Butterprint. If you do a seach on Ebay there’s always a lot of turquoise butterprint dishes and only one or two Orange or Pink Butterprint items.

At least it’s pretty clear which items that Orange Butterprint patterns appear on, and that is on Cinderella Mixing Bowls. Unlike the Turquoise Cinderella ones, the color scheme does not alternate normal and reversed among the bowls. There are 4 Cinderella Mixing bowl sizes, #441 1 1/2 pints, #442 1 1/2 quarts, #443 2 1/2 quarts and #444 4 quarts and all of them are orange on white in color. I’ve called it orange, but others call it yellow or yellow-gold.

I don’t think this was a promotional item but just that it was manufactured for release only during a certain period of time. But it seems like it is given the short supply compared to the turquoise items.

Update 3/08: Recently spotted a boxed set for the first time with a 440-SP number on it.


   Selected Pyrex items:



Vintage Pyrex Butterprint Refrigerator Dishes Turquoise
Current Price: $100.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 15h 7m



Vintage Pyrex Butterprint Covered Bowls
Current Price: $100.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 19h 50m



Vintage Pyrex Butterprint 0603 1 1/2qt Fridge Dish
Current Price: $24.94
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 19h 52m



Vintage Pyrex BUTTERPRINT Amish Nesting Mixing Bowls Set of 3 #472 #402 #403
Current Price: $55.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 20h 18m



Pyrex Butterprint Amish Refrigerator Dish Set 501-501-502-503 w/ Lids
Current Price: $149.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 22h 29m



Vintage PYREX Butterprint ~ Blue on White #443 Cinderella 2-1/2 qt Mixing Bowl
Current Price: $34.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 1d 16h 58m



Pyrex Butterprint Turquoise Blue Amish Small Refrigerator Jar or Bowl Lid 4 1/4"
Current Price: $14.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 1d 17h 46m



Pyrex Butterprint Casserole Dish 1 1/2 Quart
Current Price: $35.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 1d 17h 56m



VINTAGE Pyrex BUTTERPRINT AMISH ROOSTER Covered BUTTER DISH
Current Price: $29.95
Current Bids: 1
Ends in: 1d 20h 26m



pyrex butterprint refrigerator dish
Current Price: $80.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 2d 12h 42m



Pyrex Butterprint Amish Refrigerator Dish 0501 / Lid 501C Turquoise on White VTG
Current Price: $23.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 2d 15h 52m



2 Vintage Pyrex BUTTERPRINT Rooster 1-1/2 Cup Refrigerator Dish #501
Current Price: $34.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 2d 16h 54m



Vintage 3pc Pyrex Butterprint Blue AMISH Hex #401 402 403 Mixing Bowl Set
Current Price: $144.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 2d 21h 12m



Vintage Pyrex Butterprint #444 Cinderella Bowl
Current Price: $49.99
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 3d 4h 21m



Rare Beautiful Vintage 1957 Pyrex Butterprint Amish Refrigerator Dish Set w/Lids
Current Price: $175.00
Current Bids: 0
Ends in: 3d 8h 52m